Hi Muertos
I was led to your blog about the
Desteni I Process by a friend of mine who read it and became concerned about
me. I am a Desteni I Process ‘agent’, and after reading your blog, my friend
thought I was in a pyramid-scheme and a cult. Upon reading your blog for
myself, I found many discrepancies which I will list below. The fact that your
blog contained so much misinformation is either due to a lack of proper research,
or an attempt to persuade or influence your readers to believe what you want
them to believe (instead of presenting them with actual facts). So you are
either spreading misinformation through irresponsible research, or you are
trying to deliberately deceive your readers (which you are accusing Desteni of
doing). Either way, your blog is misleading.
At Desteni we publish everything
we do in our real names so that we can stand by everything we say. As you
stated several times, all the information is clearly indicated on the webpage,
including the pricing and the structure of the desteni I process. There is nothing
hidden and no secrets. This is an act of transparency, and not “a group that
seems to have few scruples about the techniques it uses to attract new members”.
There’s nothing to have “scruples” about; it’s all out in the open, if you’re
not interested, then don’t apply.
The growing group that supports
themselves through Desteni have this in common: we want to support people to empower
themselves to become future leaders who are willing to take on a corrupt
economic and political system, so that we can replace it with one that doesn’t
value money over life and the environment. Why? Because it makes sense: We are
destroying the planet and people are starving.
The most effective way to change
this system is through legal political democratic means, and this is a very
expensive endeavor, especially if it is self-financed. We have to be
self-financed because if we are financed by corporations like many political
leaders are, then we will be owned, as many political leaders are. And besides,
no corporation will finance a group that has equality as their political
platform, because that would mean the end of their profit. We are not
interested in profit; we are interested in financing political change. Public
policy is our tool, not revolution, activism or demonstration. But first we
need a large group of self-honest people who are ready to put their self-interest
aside and take on a world that is in very serious trouble. DIP is leadership
training that teaches you how to do this, and that also offers the financial
support necessary to exist in this world and to finance the much needed change.
The Desteni I Process gives you
the tools to be and become a leader that is capable of standing for change. If
you chose to do the process and to instead use it for self-interest, then that
is your choice. However, that is unlikely, because in doing this process, you
learn how to see through the veil of self-interest to the bigger picture, the
one where suffering and abuse is something that needs to be immediately stopped
and the one where change is long overdue.
Following is a list of discrepancies and their corrections:
About the Desteni I Process, (1) you said, “the model
functions on the basis of infinite expansion”
In actual fact, the model is
based upon a limit of 10 recruits per agent. In this way, everyone has an equal
opportunity and there is no hierarchy.
The entire structure is based on
equality so that everyone has the opportunity to learn the tools, to support
themselves while doing so, and to support others through the ‘sponsorship program’
which you forgot to mention. I personally am being sponsored, so I am not
paying for my Desteni I Process (DIP) courses. So, instead of making maximum
profit, the structure is set up to allow as many people as possible to have
access to learning the Desteni tools (self-forgiveness, self-honesty,
self-corrective application).
In fact, on the main page at
Desteni.org, there is enough free material to apply in one’s life for at least
three years. It is suggested to learn and understand the material for free at
the Desteni.org website before you make a decision to start the ‘I Process’.
Nobody should influence you in your decision; it should be a self-willed action
that is decided only after you have proved to yourself that the tools work.
Nobody can do this for you.
(2) You said “Not knowing
the laws of South Africa, where I assume the Desteni I Process business is
based, for purposes of this blog I assume that it is not technically illegal”
The Desteni I Process is an
international endeavor; I am Canadian and participate from my home. DIP follows
international business laws and is completely legal. Yes, there are many
abusive pyramid schemes out there, but DIP is not one of them.
(3) You say “Desteni
combines their MLM scheme with some of the more esoteric aspects of their cult,
thus playing on a curious mixture of their followers’ spiritual, personal and
financial motivations.”
Here you call Desteni a cult
with followers, but it is not. First of all, there is no leader, there is also no
belief system and no followers. It is stated very clearly within the Desteni
material that being a follower is not acceptable because it is not a
self-willed action- it is rather being influenced by another, be it a ‘leader’
or not. Desteni is about becoming a group of self-willed leaders who work
together cooperatively to bring about change. It is about proving to yourself
through the specific writing tools, that you can trust yourself, that you can
live the words you speak (i.e.: if you say you’re going to do something, you
actually do it). If we are able to be influenced by a leader, then we will have
no personal power, but will rather be like sheep. We have had enough of being
treated like cattle, and are ready to stand up by our own will and take a stand
against the way things currently are.
(4) You say “You’ll learn
how to talk, think and act like a Destonian, and presumably at some point
you’ll be asked to shave your head and you’ll be exposed to Desteni cult leader
Bernard Poolman’s bizarre rants about reptilian conspiracies.”
What you will actually learn is
how to be yourself, and not be influenced by others or even by yourself (for example,
I learned why I get nervous when I have to speak in front of large groups, and
how to instead remain stable and certain within myself, in this way, I stopped
influencing myself).
The face world/face off campaign
that involved head shaving is over, but I highly recommend it as a personal
challenge to face the world with no hair. It was a really cool experience and I
do recommend it to everyone, but at no point will you be asked to do it within
DIP.
From a common-sense perspective,
we use all these products for our hair, millions of us, to make it look
beautiful or to make it grow etc… but these products are super polluting and
are destroying our drinking water. It takes really intensive processes to get
chemicals out of the water, yet we continue to use more and more products. It
doesn’t make any sense to sacrifice our drinking water for beauty.
When we shaved our heads it was
a statement of putting personal ego and self-interest aside for the sake of a
natural resource that is invaluable and cannot be replaced. Besides, why do we
feel we need to look beautiful to be accepted? Why do we not accept ourselves
as we are? These are the types of questions that you will be able to face and
answer within DIP.
Some Destonians continue to
shave, others don’t. I grew my hair back and now use biodegradable shampoos/soaps
and cleaning products. I wash less and take shorter showers because the Desteni
material made me open my eyes to see that I can change many of my behaviours to
take ‘the whole’ into consideration.
(5) You said “Oh, one other thing: you can’t get a refund. The Desteni site is very
clear that once you pay your money, it’s theirs. Refunds will not be granted
for any purpose whatsoever. So if the Self-Development and Leadership Course
isn’t working for you, you can quit, but you don’t get any portion of your
money back. So, once you’re on board to
cough up nearly $14,000 to watch YouTube videos about Hitler and learn to
masturbate without looking at porn, step two is, you begin recruiting others to
get into the cult.”
Here you make it sound
like you’re going to be losing thousands of dollars if you drop out of DIP, but
in reality, if you have any uncertainty, you pay monthly- as most do- and if
you decide to stop, then you would just lose out on whatever you did not
complete that month. This is a service; I see it more as an education. It is
leadership training, so once it’s learned- you can’t return it. This is normal.
It would be like paying for school and then dropping out and asking for your
money back for the years you already completed.
Desteni doesn’t require any contracts or
anything like that to rope you in like many companies do. You pay by
month, and if you want to stop, or if you can’t afford it, you stop. If you can’t
afford it, you can apply for sponsorship and do it for free like me, all I had
to do was to show that I understood the material. You can go to desteni.org, to
the sponsorship thread on the forum, and see what it looks like to show your
understanding of the material. The main point is to get people trained to be leaders
who live life with their eyes open, not indoctrinated people who are blinded by
beliefs, religion, conspiracies or spirituality.
(6) You said “But how realistic is this? Do you know ten people who believe in
reptilian conspiracy theories, are interested in channeling Hitler and L. Ron
Hubbard through an interdimensional portal and who aspire to drop Esctasy on a
farm in South Africa?”
This is very misleading, here
you are purposefully trying to sway or influence people, which is what you are accusing
Desteni of doing. Do you see that you are doing it yourself? You swayed my friend to believe I
am in a cult, which I am most certainly not. But you’re doing it sloppily, like
saying Desteni requires you to believe in reptilian conspiracies and where we ‘aspire
to drop Ecstasy on a farm in South Africa”. This is simply not true! By using
the Desteni tools, I stopped drinking alcohol and smoking pot a long time ago,
even before I was in DIP, I simply used the tools which are available for free
on the Desteni site (I wrote a blog about it @ http://thrubreath.blogspot.ca/2011/04/mybbreakup-with-alcohol.html).
Desteni in no way supports the use of drugs,
cigarettes or alcohol. They did research years ago, and now it is thoroughly
explained why these things are not conducive to realizing who you really are,
in fact they have the opposite effect. Drugs and alcohol are more conducive to suppression,
which is counterproductive, and cigarettes pollute and support large corporations. They are also conducive to addiction, which is
allowing oneself to be moved and influenced by something other than one’s
directive principle. Drugs and alcohol are a waste of money, time and life, and
they are abusive to your physical body. This all goes against what is learned
through DIP. With DIP you learn how to use your time most effectively, how not
to be influenced even by chemical reactions within oneself such as addiction,
anxiety, fear, etc… It is a very sobering experience, and you become very aware
of exactly what you are doing to your physical body, and you become more aware
of what it needs (this has been my experience).
Also, you are not required to believe in any of the things that you named above. Within DIP it is not suggested to believe anything, but rather to test things out for yourself to prove whether or not it is effective for you and for the world. You also learn how to use common sense rather than emotions , feelings or beliefs as cues for decisions and direction. It is true that the Desteni message is a 'tough sell' because the message of equality is the most difficult message to hear as it requires considering others as yourself and placing yourself as an equal to every one else. This is contrary to our current status quo, which has us competing against each other and desiring to climb the latter of success so that we may acheive financial security and power.
Also, you are not required to believe in any of the things that you named above. Within DIP it is not suggested to believe anything, but rather to test things out for yourself to prove whether or not it is effective for you and for the world. You also learn how to use common sense rather than emotions , feelings or beliefs as cues for decisions and direction. It is true that the Desteni message is a 'tough sell' because the message of equality is the most difficult message to hear as it requires considering others as yourself and placing yourself as an equal to every one else. This is contrary to our current status quo, which has us competing against each other and desiring to climb the latter of success so that we may acheive financial security and power.
(7) You said “Yeah, what
about Poolman, anyway? Where is he in all of this? Every pyramid has an apex,
and in Desteni, Poolman is clearly sitting right on top of it. He is not only
the unquestioned leader of the Desteni cult, whose followers
literally believe he can do no wrong”
First, there is no hierarchy at
Desteni, there are only those who have a better understanding and mastery of
the tools and who are more able to support others who are still learning.
Bernard Poolman buys clothes, food and has a room to stay in, and that’s it.
You can go to the Desteni farm yourself to see this.
Also, I followed your link
called “whose followers literally believe he can do no wrong” (speaking of
Bernard Poolman) and it just led me to Daryl Thomas’s blog, which I highly recommend
everyone read, but had little mention of Bernard and no mention of believing he
can do no wrong. But remember, within Desteni there are no beliefs- only that
which can be proven to oneself, by oneself and for oneself, and the use of common sense.
(8) This one is the quote from the website you used to evaluate the
DIP (http://mlm-thetruth.com/evaluating-mlms/5step-eval/step1-endless-chain/)
“MLM programs (MLMs) typically sell “pills,
potions, or lotions” or other products that have unique appeal and promise to
deliver benefits not available elsewhere….One sees a strong sense of belonging,
or an “us versus them” cultish mentality.
DIP
teaches you to consider everyone, and to base your actions upon this
consideration. That is why we support an Equal Money System, because it is an
economic system that supports ALL- not “us versus them"- if you want to make
profit while other starve, then you are placing yourself in an “us versus them”
mentality. This is not what Desteni is promoting.
The
only group I feel “a strong sense of belonging to” is the group that includes
all life, and this is what I will stand up for: all-inclusiveness, a.k.a
oneness and equality, a.k.a an Equal Money System.
(9) MLMs depend
on unlimited recruitment of a network of endless chains of participants, and
advancement up the levels in the program is only possible through recruitment
of a pyramidal organization of participants, or “downline.”
As
I already mentioned, there is a limit of ten recruits per agent. This way,
there is no pyramidal structure, only equality and equal opportunity.
(10) You said “Yes, it’s
true—the very existence of Desteni’s MLM scheme is a contradiction. One of the
marketing hooks of this cult is that they claim to be advocating for something
called the “Equal Money System,” which is a basic guaranteed standard of living
for all people on Earth.
Yes, the Equal Money System is
the raison d’etre for DIP, but that is for each individual to realize and then
to make their own decision about.
Within DIP you will learn how to
value and consider others as yourself, and seeing the common sense in a world
where everyone is provided with the basic necessities required to live a
dignified life becomes second nature.
(11) You continue on to say “Naturally,
everyone on Earth, once the Equal Money System, comes into being will be able
to live the way millionaries do now.”
Yes, because right now only
millionaires have the security of food, good healthcare, a good education, a guaranteed
shelter and heat during the winter in cold climates, as well as financial
security in the future for themselves and their families, guaranteed transportation
and communication, guaranteed time off to relax and enjoy life- because they
have lots of money. This should be basic stuff, but right now the vast majority
of us have to live with the anxiety of not having these things (living with
anxieties such as, what if we lose our job? what if we get sick/injured? what
about retirement? How will we pay for our children’s education? Or having to
work like slaves just to keep up on bills, where some can only dream of having
a break).
(12) Then you say “This is
sort of a half-assed version of the
already severely half-assed “resource based economy” that is pushed by
another cult in the conspiracy theory business, the
Zeitgeist Movement.”
Desteni is very clear on our
stance regarding Zeitgeist and the resource based economy. The Zeitgeist
movement will never be successful because it does not use political democratic means,
therefore it will always be an illegal movement.
Also, a resourced based economy
is not practically possible because the entire world functions with money. That
is why we propose an Equal Money System, wherein money will still be utilized
to move goods, but the value of money will be backed by life, instead of
something separate from life such as debt, or a mineral such as gold. This is a
hard concept to grasp because it is so vastly different from anything we were
ever taught. For further understanding check out this blog post: (http://kimberly-kline.blogspot.ca/2012/01/response-to-mike-and-mathematically.html)
. Or check out equalmoney.org or browse the youtube videos and hundreds of
blogs on the topic by searching with the words “equal money” and “desteni."
The Equal Money System will
consist of a 2 step process, beginning first with a basic income grant (check
out the basic income pilot project in Namibia for context of what a basic
income grant is and the effects it has had (http://www.bignam.org/BIG_pilot.html)
or check out What the FAQ is equal money at our online store- yup, another
money maker: http://eqafe.com/p/what-the-faq-is-equal-money-system-volume-1).
(13) You said: “So what
gives? Why, if Desteni wants to equalize the Earth economically, are they
pushing a get-rich-quick scheme? “
There’s nothing ‘quick’ about self-change
or economic change. This is a process that takes time and requires commitment,
and it starts with a commitment to yourself. If you’re like me and have been
dealing with things like stress, anxiety (which I see as symptoms of living in a sink-or-swim profit based systemof competition and survival) and/or a lack of discipline (among
many other things that may cause an uncomfortable or conflictual inner
experience), then you will see how with the Desteni tools, you can take control
of it, and take your power back. Then you see that the commitment is nothing of
a ‘giving’ of yourself, and is more like a ‘taking back’ of yourself. You also
see that the commitment is a complete re-building of yourself from the ground
up, so that you can build yourself to be someone you can trust and respect,
someone who lives according to principles rather than experience s (a.k.a. a
consideration for all versus self-interest). Then you can start actually living the principles of the Equal Money System in your own life, so that you can participate in the process of making it a living reality.
(14) You said: “Well, in
classic cult doublespeak, Desteni leader Bernard Poolman claims that by making
everyone rich through the Desteni I Process, Destenians will eventually use their
money to buy political clout to change “the system” over to the Equal Money
System. Curiously, there’s nothing about this on the Desteni I Process
webpages; you have to drill into Poolman’s endless series of YouTube sermons in
order to appreciate this point.”
Yes, this is how we intend to
change the system from within. We have to become the politicians, the
economists and the elite in order to have any say because that is who calls the
shots today. We are currently in school studying politics, law, economics and
psychology so that we place ourselves effectively in the system, as anyone who
wants to make a real change should do. This is a personal choice each person
has to make: will you be a part of the solution? You can figure this out for
yourself as you learn within DIP. For example: no one forced me to go to university
to get my degree, no one from Desteni is influencing me when I choose which job
to take. I am making these decisions based on common sense, by looking at what
I can do to place myself effectively in society. Desteni taught me how to
effectively use the resources available to me in my life. I was born into a life where I
have three square meals, a roof over my head and access to the internet. This
is a very privileged position that most people in the world can only dream of.
This is a position of responsibility to those who are struggling to survive.
This is common sense.
The root of the problem is the
economic system that creates the framework or context within which we exist,
one which pits us against each other in a fight for survival, instead of
creating an environment of support and consideration among human beings. And
the root of that problem is who we have become within ourselves, as human
beings. That is why we say ‘self first’, because each person has to deal with
their own inner conflict and inner-deception first (for example believing you
are more important than another). We created this system based on who we are, we
have to change who we are in order to change the type of system we create.
(15) You said “Astoundingly,
I found one video by Poolman where he makes a claim that I guarantee you won’t
hear from any other huckster of an MLM scheme. He says that the Desteni I
Process will make you rich—but you’ll eventually have to give up your riches
once Desteni’s Equal Money System is instituted. Yes, you heard that right.
This MLM scheme will make you rich, but then you
have to give it back.”
Yes, absolutely. Life is not
money. Money is paper. We have agreed as humanity to accept the value of money,
and we have decided that it is more valuable than the environment and life. In reality
it is not, obviously. For me it is worth it to give up riches if I know that it
will contribute to the end of children starving and being sold into
prostitution, the end of factory farming and slave labour, and of all the
problems that are created and can be cured by politics and economics.
But we have to make money in
this world to survive, and unfortunately, those with money have more of a
voice, therefore, we need to find ways to make money in order that we may have
a voice. We are only starting at a grassroots level at the moment, and we have
a long way ahead of us. But we will not sway on our principles of equality,
oneness and doing what’s best for all instead of only doing what’s best for
those with money.
I invite you to read my process
blog where I document my use of the Desteni tools, and apply them in my daily
life @ thrubreath.blogspot.com, and my equal money blog @ Kimberly-Kline.bogspot.com.
Kim, thanks for your interest in my blog on the Desteni I Process. I've read your response and I have a few thoughts about it.
ReplyDeleteYou claim that the Desteni I Process is a means to self-finance a political/social movement to remake the world in Desteni's image. Yet, researching Desteni, I see very little evidence that this is the case. You say you're not paying for DIP courses. Who is paying, then? Somebody somewhere must be--and if you say that the proceeds of selling DIP courses is for the purpose of financing political change, there is money changing hands somewhere. So my question is: where is this money going? Do you even know where it's going? Have you ever bothered to ask where it's going?
If indeed Desteni is using this MLM scheme as a way to finance a political/social movement, where is the fund or foundation that's being used to do this? Is it a nonprofit? Whose laws (which country) is it organized under? Have you seen its profit and loss statements? If you or someone on your behalf is contributing money to an organization that you seem to describe as a non-profit, you have a right to see the finances and know where the money is going.
Why is Desteni not using this money to finance political campaigns? How many candidates is Desteni running, and for which offices? How are they paying for their campaigns? Is Desteni paying volunteers to go out there and drum up support for the Equal Money System? If so, who is paying them, how are they being paid, and where is the money coming from? You claim there's total transparency in the system. If that's truly the case, you should be able to answer these questions quite easily.
You claim that DIP cannot be a pyramid scheme or hierarchy because each agent is limited to 10 followers (in MLM speak, each distributor has a maximum downline of 10). This is nonsensical and doesn't eliminate the pyramidal structure at all. In fact, it reinforces it; if you're planning to take the world by storm but each distributor is limited to a downline of 10, you're going to need a lot more distributors, aren't you? Therefore, the 10 downline cap is in place to expand the horizontal reach of the pyramid at the bottom--but the money is still going right to the top. It's actually pretty rare in well-financed MLM schemes for a distributor to have more than 10 in their downline, because most MLM distributors make peanuts anyway. This does not alleviate my concerns whatsoever.
You claim that Desteni has no leader. What role do you believe Bernard Poolman plays in the Desteni organization? You do realize that all of the initial Desteni material--the weird videos with the chupacabra icon, Sunette Spies channeling Hitler and pieces of toilet paper, etc.--was all created and directed by Bernard Poolman, right? If he's not the leader, what is he?
Most of the justifications you present for joining the DIP are very vague statements about equality and such. There are no specifics. When Desteni members are challenged on the unsavory aspects of their group, they retreat to very bland generalities about "equality, oneness and doing what's best for all." Any further questioning of Desteni dogma usually sparks the challenged person to paint the questioner as opposing the idea of equality. That is a classic cult mind-control tactic.
I'm glad that may blog caused your friend to try to intervene. That's definitely a good friend. You are in a dangerous and destructive cult. There are resources out there for people in your situation to try to disconnect from mind control cults, but you have to want to do it. I hope you'll pull out of it because I hate to see shady people like Bernard Poolman use and abuse the trust and admiration of innocent people who fall into his orbit. Good luck to you.
Hey Muertos. I've responded to your concerns here: http://kimberly-kline.blogspot.ca/2012/04/muertos-is-concerned-about-me.html
ReplyDelete